advanced search

  • Menu
  • Home
  • Columns
    • Industry News
    • Editorials
    • Now & Then
  • Features
    • Aviation
    • Armor
    • Automotive
    • Space/Sci Fi
    • Ships
    • Figures
    • Special Reports
  • How To
    • Construction
    • Detailing
    • Painting
    • Finishing
  • First Looks
    • Aviation
    • Armor
    • Automotive
    • Space/Sci Fi
    • Ships
    • Figures
  • New Releases
    • Aviation
    • Armor
    • Automotive
    • Space/Sci Fi
    • Ships
    • Figures
    • Book Reviews
    • Tools
  • Gallery
    • Aviation
    • Armor
    • Automotive
    • Space/Sci Fi
    • Ships
    • Figures
    • Drawings
    • References
Internet Modeler : New Releases : Book Reviews RSS News Feed

Book Reviews

By Chris Banyai-Riepl

book_jg1.jpg (26761 bytes)JG 1
Histoire de la Jagdgeschwader 1 "Oesau"
Avions Collection Histoire de l'Aviation series #3

By: Eric Mombeek

Publisher: Lela Presse, 1997
ISBN: 2-9509485-2-9

I've owned Mombeek's excellent 'Defending the Reich: The History of Jagdgeschwader 1 "Oesau"' (JAC Publications) since it was published in 1992. About a year ago I started to hear that Mombeek had written a "new" French-language book on JG 1, but I was hesitant to order it sight-unseen because I didn't know how many of its photos were redundant with those in 'Defending the Reich.' Last week I finally took the plunge, and the answer turns out to be "roughly two-thirds." However, please keep reading ...

'JG 1: Histoire de la Jagdgeschwader 1 "Oeseau",' by Mombeek (Avions Collection Histoire de l'Aviation series, No. 3; Lela Presse, 1997), contains 414 pages, whereas 'Defending the Reich' had 330. Much of the additional space is devoted to new photos, and many of those are outstanding. The only real downside of the newer book, for me, is that it's entirely in French, but those of us with even a smattering of high-school French will be able to understand the gist of most of the photos' captions. And the photos *are* wonderful; as examples (some of which were in 'Defending the Reich"):

  • Heydrich's Bf 109E, showing its SS rune marking (p. 35);
  • Bf 109Gs with red Reich-Defense bands (p. 276-278);
  • a Bf 109G with an unusual "<>+" Stab marking (p. 277);
  • a Bf 109G-10 in overall-76 [or overall-77] camouflage (p. 276);
  • Fw 190As with red Reich-Defense bands (p. 239, 241, 247, 249-251, 278, 280, 284, 288);
  • Fw 190As with black & white striped (p. 148, 216-220, 223, 224, 228) or checkerboard (p. 169-171, 186, 187, 198, 206) cowls;
  • a Fw 190A-4 (p. 151) and a Fw 190A-5 (p. 158) with green "Tanzelwurm" and "<0+-" Stab markings;
  • a Fw 190A-5[?] with a uniquely-painted spinner (p. 157);
  • two of Bär's Fw 190A-8s (p. 251); and
  • Galland's personal Fh 104 [Si 104] (p. 133)

Also new are five pages of color profile paintings and several helpful detail photos -- for example, a particularly nice shot of a Bf 109E's cowl cooling slots, through which we can see the engine block (p. 19). I purchased my copy from Articles of War for US$67.50 plus postage.

Is the newer book worth its price? That depends, I think. If you harbor any interest in Fw 190s and/or Luftwaffe camouflage & markings and don't have 'Defending the Reich' already -- or if you own 'Defending the Reich' but previously-unpublished photos of '190s, Reich-Defense bands and cowl markings always give you a thrill -- then I feel confident that your answer will be "Yes" (or even "YES!!"). On the other hand, if a copy of 'Defending the Reich' is on your shelves already and Luftwaffe aircraft aren't a personal passion, then I'd urge you to inspect the newer book closely ... but not to buy it until you've done so. FWIW, I'm *very* happy to have *both* books.

Charles Metz

 


book_a20.jpg (28613 bytes)Douglas A-20 Havoc/Boston
Monografie No 41

Publisher: A/J press

ISBN: 83-86209-83-X

Pages: 109

14 pages of drawings One in 1/36 scale the rest in 1/72 6 pages of color drawings.

The excellent Monografie series continues with this latest addition, all on the Douglas DB-7/A-20 family. Here is a book that will show you all the A-20 s in very nice 1/72 scale drawings from the Model –7 to the –G.

The book also has some very interesting pictures of the aircraft. The best ones are the Russian aircraft. How would you like to see an A-20 with a torpedo on the side of the A/C. and have a drawing to go along with it? It's in here.
Other neat pictures include some of the best I have seen showing A-20s with the three-tube bazookas under the wings.

This book will also expand your horizons and make you a more worldy person, as all the text is in Polish. Pictures do say a thousand words, though, so even if you don't want to learn Polish, you can get a lot of information from this book.

So go pick up a couple more AMT A-20s from the local closeout shops, grab this book, and crank out some interesting A-20s.

Will Riepl


book_germanknights.jpg (30468 bytes)German Knights of the Air 1914-1918
The Holders of the Orden Pour le Merite

Author: Terry C. Treadwell & Alan C. Wood

Publisher: Barnes & Noble, 1998

ISBN: 0-7607-0790-1

Pages: 208

Books on World War One aviation are not as common as other eras, which is why it was good to see this title at the local Barnes and Noble bookstore.
Not only was it inexpensive (around $14), it is filled with some well written studies on each of the 81 German airmen who won the Orden Pour le Merite, or "Blue Max" as it is sometimes called. A glimpse of each pilot is given, covering his life and the action for which he received his award.

The pictures included are very well done, and are large enough to glean enough data to model some of them. Everything from balloons to Albatri to Fokker Dr.Is and D.VIIIs are presented, all in the markings of some of the most famous and notorious German aviators of World War One.

If you have a large library of WWI books, this one might be somewhat redundant, but if you are just starting to collect WWI references, this book is well worth the price.

Chris Banyai-Riepl

MODELER'S WEAPONS SHOP GUIDES

Two very handy modeler's guides are available from The Modeler's Weapons Shop. Both are written by INTERNET MODELER's very own Richard Marmo, who isn't about to toot his own horn about these in "ScaleWorld," but they are definitely worth checking out.

Whether you have gotten so advanced yourself that you're ready to start creating your own cast resin aftermarket pieces for that kit that just cries out for a bit more detail, or whether you'd just like to know what goes into those beauties from KMC, Meteor, True Details and the other resin manufacturers, The Modeler's Weapons Shop Guide to Resin Construction, Part 1 & Part 2 are very worthwhile reading. Part 1 deals with vbasic concepts and the history of resin and RTV, along with tools, adhesives and paint as they relate to resin kits. You may never make your own stuff, but after you read this, you will be far better equipped to work with the cast resin kits you buy. Part 2 is not yet out, but will deal with specific construction techniques in detail. The booklet is xeroxed, and retails for US$4.95>

The Modeler's Weapons Shop Guide to Model Math and Scale Jumping is exactly what it says. Got drawings for that bit you need to scratchbuild, but you flunked junior high math and it was twenty years ago anyway, maybe more? Forget trying to remember what you never learned anyway, going nuts with enlarging grids and trying to calculate percentages for enlarging or reducing drawings in the copier. Use this simple guide and feel like the genius you always knew was lurking around there somewhere. This guide sells for US$3.95.

I wasn't that sure I needed either of these guides when they arrived in the mail, but I have already improved my work in resin on a project sitting on the workbench, and the drawings I needed to correct a part were easy with the math guide. Recommended.

Reviewed by:
Tom Cleaver

Buyers should note that when ordering Guides only, U.S. customers should add US$1.50 per Guide, while foreign purchasers should add US$3.50 for postage and packing. Payment is by money order or check. Foreign orders in U.S. funds by American Express Traveller's Check or American Express Money Order please. To order on the net: https://www.tricky.com/modeler/